Unshaken

As is typical I always end up way too late on the fanart train, so let's just imagine it's 2018 again and we're playing RDR2.
Finally grabbed it in a sale recently and hoh boy is it a great game. Admittedly i was prepared for all the annoying railroading during missions that game does, so i accepted my fate and just went with whatever the game wanted to show me, rather than try and do weird open world stuff, but story wise it's a fantastic thing.
It's the first game that managed to create a weird feeling of not wanting to start the game over because it'd be weird to disturb where the characters are at and just reset them.